AFIP: From listening to action

By Chizoba Esio-Bassey

About the author

Dr Chizoba Esio-Bassey is a Senior Lecturer in Public Health at UWE Bristol and EDI Cluster Lead for Cluster 3 in the School of Health and Social Wellbeing.

Case study background

This case study presents Anonymous Feedforward for Inclusive Practice (AFIP), a five-step cycle that starts with a short anonymous survey to find learning barriers.

Introduction: about me and those involved

I am Dr Chizoba Esio-Bassey, Senior Lecturer in Public Health at UWE Bristol and EDI Cluster Lead for Cluster 3 in the School of Health and Social Wellbeing. AFIP grew out of my interest in turning commitments to equality, diversity and inclusion into practical changes in everyday teaching.

I first shared the idea at an EDI Connect Lunch Meet-up, inviting colleagues to explore it and imagine how it might work in practice. Their responses shaped AFIP from the start. Colleagues contributed to survey questions, ways to analyse responses, possible teaching adjustments and digital tools to support the process.

One suggestion changed the direction of the project. My colleague Issy Bray proposed running AFIP at programme level rather than through separate module surveys. This would cause a more coordinated approach: less duplication, fewer surveys for students and a clearer view of barriers to learning and the needs of students across modules.

AFIP has evolved through the contributions and collaboration with colleagues who helped in shaping AFIP into a practical approach.

The problem: why was AFIP needed?

Every cohort arrives with different educational experiences, cultural backgrounds, responsibilities and levels of confidence. Some students face barriers linked to disability, health, caring responsibilities, finances, language, digital access or confidence in speaking up in class.

Yet most of our feedback mechanisms ask students to reflect after teaching has happened. That feedback is valuable but it often arrives too late to help the students who gave it.

Focus groups, co-design workshops and student partnership activities help, but they usually involve speaking openly to staff or peers. Not every student is ready to do that especially at the start of a course, before trust has had time to build.

This leaves a gap: how can students tell us what might affect their learning before teaching begins without having to identify themselves or disclose anything publicly?

AFIP was designed to fill that gap.

The solution: what is AFIP?

AFIP is an anonymous, forward-looking approach to inclusive teaching. By anonymously gathering information from students at the start of a module or programme about their needs, backgrounds and preferences, staff gain insight that directly informs how the learning environment is designed and adapted.

It is not just another feedback survey. What sets it apart is its timing and its purpose. Instead of asking students what went wrong, it asks one simple question:

“What can we do now to create an inclusive learning environment for you?”

This shifts the focus from looking back to acting ahead. It also recognises that inclusive practice does not require staff to know everything about every student. It requires creating the opportunity to listen and then acting on what we hear.

How AFIP works: the five-step model

AFIP follows five steps that form a continuous cycle of listening, action and improvement.

The AFIP model · five steps in a continuous cycle

1. Ask: give students a chance to share. Before teaching begins, or in the very first session, students complete a short anonymous survey using Mentimeter about what might get in the way of their learning and what would help. For example:

  • What might make it difficult for you to take part fully in learning activities?
  • Are there teaching or learning activities you find challenging?
  • What helps you feel comfortable taking part in class?
  • Is anything about the timing, location or format of teaching likely to make attendance difficult?
  • Do you use assistive technology we should consider when preparing materials?
  • Is there anything else that could help us create a more inclusive learning environment?

The survey is brief, optional, written in plain language and genuinely anonymous. It never asks for identifying or sensitive information.

2. Analyse: look for patterns. Staff review responses for common themes. The aim is not to identify individuals but to understand what might hold the cohort back such as unstructured group work, anxiety about being put on the spot, unclear assessment instructions, fast verbal explanations or the need to ask questions anonymously.

3. Act: make practical adjustments. Staff then make realistic, proportionate changes. Depending on what students raise and these might include:

  • clearer assessment guidance, checklists and worked examples;
  • structured roles for group activities;
  • slides and materials shared in advance;
  • anonymous channels for questions;
  • materials that work with assistive technology;
  • a wider range of examples and case studies;
  • different ways to take part, including discussion boards and chat.

AFIP does not promise that every request can be met. Instead, it ensures that feasible changes are made, informed by what students actually tell us.

4. Communicate: close the loop. Staff tell students what has changed using a simple “You told us, we listened, we changed” message. This shows students their voices count and builds trust in the process.

5. Review: learn and improve. Midway through the module, staff check with students whether the changes have helped, note any barriers that remain and refine the approach for the next cohort. Inclusion becomes an ongoing cycle, not a one-off task.

How AFIP differs from traditional feedback

Traditional feedbackAFIP
Collected after teaching has taken placeCollected before or at the very start of teaching
Asks students to reflect on their experienceAsks what would help students take part and learn
Usually benefits future cohortsCan shape the learning experience of current students
Retrospective and reactiveForward-looking and proactive

AFIP complements rather than replaces existing feedback, student partnership and co-creation activities. It is not a diagnostic tool, a substitute for formal reasonable adjustments, or a requirement for students to disclose personal information. It is simply one more way for students to be heard especially before they feel ready to speak openly.

Challenges encountered

Developing AFIP has raised practical questions that need careful answers if the approach is to be meaningful, manageable and sustainable.

  • Balancing anonymity with the need to respond. Anonymity helps students speak freely, but it means staff cannot follow up individually. AFIP must therefore sit alongside, not replace established routes to individual support and reasonable adjustments.
  • Asking the right questions. Questions must be broad enough to capture different experiences without becoming intrusive, and quick and easy to answer.
  • Turning information into action. Responses only matter if staff have the time, confidence and resources to act on them. Colleagues need support to move from identifying barriers to making realistic changes.
  • Avoiding duplication and extra workload. Separate surveys for every module risk survey fatigue for students and extra work for staff. A programme-level approach offers a more efficient way to identify shared barriers.
  • Managing expectations. Students need to understand what AFIP is for and what can realistically change. Staff must be honest that not every suggestion can be adopted, while showing that every response is taken seriously.
  • Protecting data and trust. The process must be genuinely anonymous with clear information on how responses are used, who sees them and how they are stored.

These questions are shaping AFIP’s ongoing development and will be explored further through piloting and evaluation.

Feedback from staff and students

Staff feedback and collaboration

The EDI Connect Lunch Meet-up gave colleagues the chance to engage with AFIP and help shape it. Their ideas on survey design, analysing responses, teaching adjustments and digital tools helped to shape AFIP.

Issy Bray’s suggestion to collect AFIP responses at programme level was especially influential. It reframed how AFIP could be introduced in a coordinated and sustainable way. Colleagues also stressed the need for clear guidance and practical exemplar actions so that staff feel confident turning responses into changes in their teaching.

Student feedback

We have already carried out the AFIP survey using Mentimeter with MSc Public Health students at UWE. It gave us valuable insight into the barriers that could make it difficult for students to engage fully in their modules.

Student voice is at the heart of AFIP. As the approach moves into practice, the next step is to hear from students about the process itself: whether the survey is accessible, whether anonymity makes them more comfortable sharing and whether they notice real changes as a result.

Next steps

The next stage is to move AFIP from concept to practice and test how well it works.

  1. Develop an AFIP toolkit with a bank of suggested questions, survey templates, example adjustments and guidance on analysing responses.
  2. Explore programme-level implementation, building on the idea raised at EDI Connect to reduce duplication and identify shared barriers.
  3. Pilot the approach with selected programme teams to test the survey and see how responses can shape teaching.
  4. Explore digital tools, including Mentimeter and Microsoft Forms to support anonymous data collection, analysis and reporting in line with data protection requirements.
  5. Embed “You told us, we listened, we changed” so that staff routinely share the actions taken in response to students.
  6. Gather student and staff feedback on AFIP’s accessibility, usefulness, feasibility and influence on teaching.
  7. Review and refine the questions, guidance and model before considering wider adoption.

The ambition is for AFIP to become a practical, programme-wide approach to listen to students earlier, respond to barriers sooner and keep improving the inclusivity of our learning environments.

Top tips for colleagues

  • Ask early. Don’t wait until the end of a module to find out what held students back. Ask before teaching begins.
  • Make anonymity real. Avoid names, logins or anything that could identify a student.
  • Keep it short and simple. Use plain language and a survey students can finish in a few minutes.
  • Look forward, not back. Ask what would help students take part, not only what went wrong.
  • Don’t assume everyone will speak up. Offer more than one way for students to share.
  • Look for patterns, not individuals. Focus on barriers in the learning environment, not on who said what.
  • Turn responses into action. A survey alone changes nothing. Prioritise changes that are feasible and meaningful.
  • Close the loop. Tell students what changed because of what they said.
  • Work together. Shared ownership across programme teams makes AFIP more consistent and sustainable.
  • Keep refining. AFIP is not about getting everything right first time. It is about continuing to listen, learn and improve.

Conclusion

AFIP rests on a simple principle: inclusive practice begins by listening to students early and anonymously, so that barriers to learning can be identified and addressed to create a more inclusive environment for students.

What began as an idea at an EDI Connect Lunch Meet-up has grown through the contributions of staff. The next step is to test it widely, learn from students and staff and show how it can lead to real change in teaching and learning.

Inclusive practice does not mean knowing everything about every student. It means creating the opportunity to listen and making feasible adjustments based on what we have heard.

Ask early. Listen anonymously. Act purposefully. Review continuously.